MT3 V.S. MT2

[Susquatch]

This model has the 2 adjustments providing you get the indicator head as shown. I think this style comes in both mini mag base & next larger arm size up, but you'd have to confirm the catalog.

NOGA,NOGA DG6160 DBL FINE ADJUSTMENT MAG BASE,1-457-917,KBC Tools & Machinery

NOGA,NOGA DG6160 DBL FINE ADJUSTMENT MAG BASE,1-457-917,KBC Tools & Machinery

www.kbctools.ca

It is absolutely beautiful! Perfect!

Is it my imagination or does that end have three different indicator mounts - two sizes of stubs and one dovetail?

Edit - KBCs website says it actually has 5 different mounts - 6mm, 8mm, 3/8", dovetail, and back lug.

Price is up there, but it really is perfect!

The Yeti is happy......!

 

[6.5 Fan]

I see that KBC has the Noga with fine adjustment at the top on sale now for $156.62

 

[Susquatch]

I see that KBC has the Noga with fine adjustment at the top on sale now for $156.62

Ordered.

Huge thanks to all!

 

[Dusty]

Trust me like what @PeterT 's #19 post and @Dabbler 's comments, you'll never regret having having a NOGA magnetic base with both FAT / FAB adjustments. Absolute perfection!

https://www.noga.com/Products/FATFAB/Articulated Holders FAT |famp| FAB

 

[Susquatch]

Trust me like what @PeterT 's #19 post and @Dabbler 's comments, you'll never regret having having a NOGA magnetic base with both FAT / FAB adjustments. Absolute perfection!

https://www.noga.com/Products/FATFAB/Articulated Holders FAT |famp| FAB

Already ordered. When that many guys love them that much I don't need to think about it. When I saw the adjustments on both ends, I was sold. Can't wait to try it!

 

[YYCHM]

I got a NOGA this year. Should have gotten it years ago. Those rod type holders are such a PITA to use.

 

[YYCHM]

I wanted to revisit this MT3 v.s. MT2, are they close enough issue and made a MT2 Dead Center using the same taper attachment setup I used to make some MT3 Dead Centers.....



I would say YES close enough. Unfortunately the piece of scrap I chose to use was a bit on the short side. I overshot the small OD and had to extend the taper a bit to make up for that error which shorted the whole taper ever more.



To turn the point, I put the taper into a MT2/MT3 sleeve and mounted it in my spindle. That worked well.



As I said it turned out to be a little on the short side LOL...

Craig

 

[PeterT]

Craig, how did your blue rub off test turn out in terms of how the arbor MT matches your machine sockets MT? Reason I ask (and this might just be paranoia on my part) if your rub-off is confined to a relatively shorter width band near the front & the remainder of the rear surface is more or less non/partial contact, it will probably 'feel' like its mating, but in reality may not be to a sufficient extent. Any axial force and/or rotational force like in typical lathe use will be entirely concentrated on that fractional area. Your machine surfaces are probably hardened & your machined part probably slightly softer material, but that doesn't mean that wear or distortion can't occur on your machine surface, which would be a bad thing. Nothing against making your own tooling at all, but in this particular application I'd confirm fit by blue-ing. I've read sad tales where people are buying special $$ MT taper reamers with mixed results, or otherwise asking how to 'fix' their buggered MT taper seats. The story rarely ends well. I've always wondered how it got that way to begin with. Surface corrosion or trapping swarf might explain some of the minor issues. But some of the bell mouthing effect & spin direction gouges could be result of wrong tool taper & applying typical machining forces.

 

[YYCHM]

Craig, how did your blue rub off test turn out in terms of how the arbor MT matches your machine sockets MT? Reason I ask (and this might just be paranoia on my part) if your rub-off is confined to a relatively shorter width band near the front & the remainder of the rear surface is more or less non/partial contact, it will probably 'feel' like its mating, but in reality may not be to a sufficient extent. Any axial force and/or rotational force like in typical lathe use will be entirely concentrated on that fractional area. Your machine surfaces are probably hardened & your machined part probably slightly softer material, but that doesn't mean that wear or distortion can't occur on your machine surface, which would be a bad thing. Nothing against making your own tooling at all, but in this particular application I'd confirm fit by blue-ing. I've read sad tales where people are buying special $$ MT taper reamers with mixed results, or otherwise asking how to 'fix' their buggered MT taper seats. The story rarely ends well. I've always wondered how it got that way to begin with. Surface corrosion or trapping swarf might explain some of the minor issues. But some of the bell mouthing effect & spin direction gouges could be result of wrong tool taper & applying typical machining forces.

I don't think it's long enough to do a blue rub off check LOL...

 

[Dabbler]

You can blue any size part, Craig...

 

[YYCHM]

You can blue any size part, Craig...

The taper is too short to do a blue rub off check in my tailstock.

 

[PeterT]

Did you shorten it or something? You have lots of length there to check. Hopefully I'm not beating a dead horse, maybe picture will help. I'm not saying this is your situation, just example. If the rub-off area is confined to a short silver band, then that's where all the force goes. The rear area that remains predominantly blue isn't in full contact, so its not contributing to centering or load distribution. That's all I'm really trying to say.

 

[YYCHM]

Did you shorten it or something? You have lots of length there to check. Hopefully I'm not beating a dead horse, maybe picture will help. I'm not saying this is your situation, just example. If the rub-off area is confined to a short silver band, then that's where all the force goes. The rear area that remains predominantly blue isn't in full contact, so its not contributing to centering or load distribution. That's all I'm really trying to say.

I understand what you are getting at but the taper is too short to do a rub check.....

 

[PeterT]

Do you mean the tapered portion inside your tailstock barrel is short? I don't understand.
If so, how about the headstock end. I would think that has to be at least couple inches long, no?

 

[YYCHM]

Do you mean the tapered portion inside your tailstock barrel is short? I don't understand.
If so, how about the headstock end. I would think that has to be at least couple inches long, no?

Ok, describe how to perform your blue rub check, maybe I don't understand what it is?

The taper in the tailstock quill is pretty much the length of the entire dead center taper.

 

[PeterT]

Clean both surfaces, use a wide tip felt pen Sharpie marker, paint the entire male arbor, insert into female socket with light push, turn arbor 1/4-1/2 turn or so, pull straight out, observe results. What rubbed off & where? To repeat you may have to first wipe both surfaces clean again. Methanol works very well to remove marker from metal. Disposable gloves are helpful.

You will also hear 'blue-ing' as in the compound that machinists use. It usually comes in a tube, a petroleum based kind of greasy feeling substance (think like a tube of oil paint). It can be used in this way as well but its a bit fussier because it only dries when very thin & can smear a bit. More typically its applied very thin on machined surfaces or granite plates & the transfer (or lack of) shows where material needs to be scraped or otherwise conditioned. The Sharpie marker method above is easy to implement, probably with what you have in the shop. So black, blue, purple... any ideally dark color that you can see contrast to bare silvery metal.

 

[PeterT]

Hey, aren't you already doing it? This is from your pics no?

 

[YYCHM]

Hey, aren't you already doing it? This is from your pics no?

Ya, that's layout fluid and it really doesn't work that well for this. A felt marker might be better. The problem is.... look at the image of the dead center mounted in the tailstock. How am I going grab it in order to twist it 1/4-1/2 turn, I would have to turn another taper as a test piece, which I may do.

 

[PeterT]

Oh, you mean you used layout blue? What I was referring to is called hi-spot (or different things depending on manufacturer). Different stuff again.

DYKEM 83307 Hi-Spot Blue Type, Manual Type of Power Etcher

The ideal way to identify high spots on bearings and gear surfacesApplicationsMost valuable when scraping flat bearing surfacesFeaturesNon-drying.Transfers from one surface to another.For locating high spots when scraping bearing surfaces & in making close fits.Soft, smooth, uniform paste...

www.traverscanada.com

 

[PeterT]

Ya, now that its made, may be kind of difficult to grab onto the point end & do the twist motion. Pure insertion & retraction might tell you a little bit but the rub might be faint or more localized. That's why I was saying somewhere way up the post, it's best if you have something like a reference MT socket to bring up to the work while in the lathe as its being made. That's really when you are in a position do something about it.