• Scam Alert. Members are reminded to NOT send money to buy anything. Don't buy things remote and have it shipped - go get it yourself, pay in person, and take your equipment with you. Scammers have burned people on this forum. Urgency, secrecy, excuses, selling for friend, newish members, FUD, are RED FLAGS. A video conference call is not adequate assurance. Face to face interactions are required. Please report suspicions to the forum admins. Stay Safe - anyone can get scammed.

Over-Unity / Perpetual Motion Machine / Non-conventionally powered devices….. ever tried to build one?

Ever thought about or tried to build one? Or think it’s Bat-$*** dumb and a waste of time?

  • I’ve built one. Currently powers my house.

    Votes: 3 12.0%
  • I’ve built one. Men in black came and took my machine from me at gunpoint.

    Votes: 3 12.0%
  • I’ve built one. Didn’t work, but was fun and I’m glad I did it.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’ve built one, I was suckered into believing it, but it was a waste of time.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I’ve never built one, but unconventional energy sources is an interesting topic.

    Votes: 10 40.0%
  • I’ve never built one, I don’t believe any unconventional energy sources exist, but I get the appeal.

    Votes: 4 16.0%
  • I’ve never built one, no interest. We have reached the pinnacle of technology already.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • If you believe in any of that stuff your bat-$*** crazy.

    Votes: 12 48.0%

  • Total voters
    25
Status
Not open for further replies.
On the other hand those other people think they can win at the Casino

Interesting comment Tom.

I don't go to casinos and I don't buy lottery tickets. Prolly does go hand in hand with not believing in perpetual motion.

Sometimes people colloquially use "free energy" to mean "infinite or costless energy", but in science, "free" strictly means available or unbound. They are two totally different concepts.

For example, perpetual motion does exist in the universe on a relative scale. Setting such debated things like nuclear deterioration, the life span of stars and galaxies, and big bang theory aside, stars do drift through empty space on a collasal scale - seemingly without expending any energy to do so.

But I believe we are talking here about the non-scientific concept of "infinite or costless energy". For example, an engine that infinitely does work without adding energy from external sources to do that work.

I further suspect that @BaitMaster has a particular interest in very low power devices that seemingly operate infinitely by using localized energy to drive their "perceived perpetual motion". These are definitely cool. I'd love to have one too.

I recall that a Dean of Engineering I knew had a Stirling Engine on a side table in his office. These clever little engines harvest the difference in energy between two plates at different temperatures to expand and contract the air in a chamber to drive the engines rotation. His was sensitive enough to operate from the table top heat generated from his office lighting vs the air temperature above the table.

There are many other examples of similar devices. They are not really perpetual motion machines. But they are marvelous in their own right and easily catch the eye of those machinists who are interested in the precision required to make one that uses such low energy sources to operate.
 
Hi Guys,
One example springs to mind, often seen and sold in novelty shops is the device where a magnet is embedded in the base of a stand with an arm supporting a second magnet on a length of rod loosely pivoted at the top. The two magnetic fields interact with each other causing the pendulum to swing back and forth purely due to the weight of the magnet on the end of the pendulum and the magnetic interaction.
 
Hi Guys,
One example springs to mind, often seen and sold in novelty shops is the device where a magnet is embedded in the base of a stand with an arm supporting a second magnet on a length of rod loosely pivoted at the top. The two magnetic fields interact with each other causing the pendulum to swing back and forth purely due to the weight of the magnet on the end of the pendulum and the magnetic interaction.
That is unlikely just becasue magnetism alone. It is, IMO, some electronic circuitry hidden in the vase that creates pulsing magnetic field to swing the pendulum. And, of course there is a battery somewhere :O)
 
Hi Guys,
One example springs to mind, often seen and sold in novelty shops is the device where a magnet is embedded in the base of a stand with an arm supporting a second magnet on a length of rod loosely pivoted at the top. The two magnetic fields interact with each other causing the pendulum to swing back and forth purely due to the weight of the magnet on the end of the pendulum and the magnetic interaction.

These fall in the category of fakes. As @Gennady suggests, they all have a hidden battery. Sometimes deliberately inaccessible.
 
I once read a book.

Our laws of physics are obviously created by us. So how do we really know anything for certain? Everytime someone makes a statement saying they know something for certain just give it some time.


And that guy that was mentioned who has spent 35 years toiling away in his shop not getting anywhere but probably as happy as a kid in a candy store...show of hands...anyone?
 
Our laws of physics are obviously created by us. So how do we really know anything for certain? Everytime someone makes a statement saying they know something for certain just give it some time.

I'm with you on that. Science constantly changes as we challenge old ideas and generate new knowledge. Invariably, even among scientists and physicists, there are those who stick with whatever they learned in the past, those who jump onto the latest hot science, and those who tread carefully and change slowly. I'm a regular member of each tribe.

And that guy that was mentioned who has spent 35 years toiling away in his shop not getting anywhere but probably as happy as a kid in a candy store...show of hands...anyone?

Ya, nothing wrong with that kind of happiness.
 
I think that if there were only unbelievers about many things ,we would still be running around in fig leaves and grunting.
Many of the things we have now, would have people burnt at the stake a few hundred years ago.
I am not saying there’s nothing out there, but many things can be improved to work better, run longer, be more reliable.
Just some of the battery’s available now to the general public are very amazing, and the very short recharge times for them.
Perpetual motion, well, even the rotation of the earth is said to be slowing down, the sun powers down in some odd billion years. Perpetual is kind of meaningless if you won’t be around to measure it.
 
I think that if there were only unbelievers about many things ,we would still be running around in fig leaves and grunting.
Many of the things we have now, would have people burnt at the stake a few hundred years ago.
I am not saying there’s nothing out there, but many things can be improved to work better, run longer, be more reliable.
Just some of the battery’s available now to the general public are very amazing, and the very short recharge times for them.
Perpetual motion, well, even the rotation of the earth is said to be slowing down, the sun powers down in some odd billion years. Perpetual is kind of meaningless if you won’t be around to measure it.
Do you believe the sun is real?

So much of what we are taught to believe may be incorrect

Yes, it's egregious but it's also not that far off track

I'm going back to communism
 
One of the most common problems is that people refer to science as if it is a set of knowledge. Science is a method of finding things out!

Think about what might be true, devise an experiment that can test that idea, and repeat it enough times to get a result. Then describe it so that others can confirm (or not) your results

Science is a method that is totally unable to describe non-repeatable events. There is no way for science to describe what I ate for breakfast last Tuesday for example. It is very useful for understanding the laws of nature, but not where there is volition involved (i.e. I could have chosen toast or eggs; or nothing; or just coffee; or, or or 😉

In school, science is generally taught as a set of facts though. I think most of the teachers don't really understand the distinction between the process of finding things out and the things that were found out via a scientific process

When it comes to perpetual motion, there doesn't seem to be any evidence that such a device can be built; and ample evidence that it can't. Entropy (enthalpy) is a well supported concept and we all have practical examples in our shops. Take a piece of stock and chuck it up. You can make chips without too much effort, but to take the chips and turn them back into stock is much harder 😉

But there are sources of energy all around us. Even without modern technology, the sun, the motion of the moon, the rotation of the earth and it's magnetic field are all potential sources of energy. And of course anywhere there is wifi or cell service or GPS signal or even AM radio has man made sources of energy available. Devices that can function with a small enough need for energy, or can consume these sources very efficiently, can appear to have perpetual motion. They are usually hard to build and super cool!
 
So when a asteroid strikes earth why is there a crater and not a groove followed by a crater.

Earth's rotation speed depends on your latitude. At the equator, the planet spins at roughly 1,674 km/h (1,040 mph or 465 m/s) to complete one rotation in 24 hours.
 
Thats one reason why nasa launches from Florida and not Alaska- it takes less rocket fuel to get to orbit if you already have more speed / energy by being closer to the equator

When shooting a flying bird, you can get a grove if it is a glancing hit, but most of the time the shot seems to go strait in because it is moving so much faster than the bird. Asteroids move much faster than the earth rotates, but I suppose it is possible. The gravity of the earth will also bend the trajectory to make the impact more direct though, so I think it would be very hard for that to happen
 
why nasa launches from Florida and not Alaska
That is right but your orbit will not cover all Earth surface - only equatorial areas. And if you want to fly over norten and polar territories you need to "shoot" more and more across the globe. If you want to cover all the surface you need to launch strictly to the north or south - then it does not matter where is your launching pad. Moreover - there are countries that always launching against the rotation of the globe due to their geographical position. n this case Earth is not helping you but, actually, counteracting.
 
See!!!! This is why I love this forum. Although I love astronomy, I never realized that most craters were round let alone knew why. Each and every day I become richer thanks to all of you!
 
giphy.gif
 
Science is a method that is totally unable to describe non-repeatable events. There is no way for science to describe what I ate for breakfast last Tuesday for example. It is very useful for understanding the laws of nature, but not where there is volition involved (i.e. I could have chosen toast or eggs; or nothing; or just coffee; or, or or 😉

Just want to add that social sciences exists which is science but with human and socioecomic systems! There is of course volitilty with human components and agency which makes the chaos (for me) all the more fun! I think it's not thought of conventionally like a science because it isn't a "hard" science with universal law-like models but there is still much theorizing and research. Many things in "life" are socially constructed including why one would chose toast or eggs or nothing for breakfast.
 
Other than perpetual motion, I'm not even sure what we're talking about, unless it's just "Hey! I've created a free lunch!". Before the advent of semiconductors (and that was in my lifetime) solar power was "unconventional" or maybe not even conceived of. Before the relationship of magnetism and electricity was understood (and historically that is quite recent), no one imagined plain old hydro power.

What are the boundaries of "unconventional"?



Biodiesel is old hat, and a "pure vegetable oil" compression-ignition engine does not even require the step of shortening the molecular chains, maybe just a bit of pre-heating to lower the viscosity. (Apparently Rudolf Diesel originally thought peanut oil would be running his invention.)

I don't really like either from an ecological/pollution point of view - it seems that burning pretty much anything creates byproducts that we'd be better off without, even if the thing being burned is 100% renewable.

One of my favorite mad science writers decided that although their time machine required as much energy as was in the entire universe, they simply got around that by stealing the energy of a convenient alternate universe... You just gotta think outside the box. Even if it's a VERY large box...
A friend of mine bought a brand new 2 cyl Lister Diesel Engine with the intention of running it off old deep fryer oil. However once that became more popular access became limited and it wasn't the most fuel efficient engine to begin with.
I believe it's for sale again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top