It was the first burnt finish that I tried and I have mixed feelings about it. The main reason I did it (along with treating the wood with boiled linseed oil) was to preserve the wood and it gives the handle a nice feel in the hand. It doesn't slip when my hand gets sweaty like many of my commercially made varnished handles that need to be sanded before any serious use. As far as the aesthetics go, I certainly was not going for a hipster vibe or to make the tool appear to be used.
Just wait until you get to the level of having to make a tool, to make a tool, so you can make the tool you are actually trying to make...
Or you discover Repoussé, and that you need about a thousand hammers to get all the way through what you wish to do! And the chisels and punches! LOL! Worse by far, than auto body work!
Not trying to stomp on yer parade, just expressing my views. Burnt wood goes back into the stove, IM(nsh)O. I kinda started my hate on for the stuff back in Grade 8 Shop, where the teacher made us all put a torch to some perfectly nice clear Pine... Not so concerned if some Japanese guy in a rain forest thought it made his hut last longer in the wet, more concerned with not having ugly scorched stuff around.
I am partial to a nice oil finish, to bring out the color and act as a bit of a preservative, and then allowing a nice handle or part, to develop it's marks and wear with honest use!
Agree 100 percent, WRT the crappy slick clear coat that they put on the shelf goods, too!