Tool Keyed or keyless tailstock chuck?

[DavidR8]

I realized today that I don't have a tailstock chuck for the new lathe.
Question for the group: do I get a keyed or keyless chuck?

 

[SomeGuy]

Keyless is so much faster...there's some times when a keyed one will hold better, but honestly the keyless grip shockingly well.

 

[140mower]

I so love my keyless Albright...... Just saying. Although to be truthful, I also use a keyed chuck with a center drill it at all times. So, my vote is for 2 chucks.....

 

[whydontu]

Keyed or Keyless?

The answer is yes.

Ailing power drills usually cost about $10 at thrift stores. For my B2227L lathe with MT2 tailstock, a 3/8”-24 x MT2 arbor runs about $15.

 

[Former Member]

Keyless, Accusize offers a good one. I've already got 2, for the mill and drill press, lucky that drill press uses the MT3 like the lathe, but a third is on the list.

 

[Susquatch]

3 of each or more. Need small, medium, and large. Have nice keyless Southbend and GS - still looking for Albrechts.

 

[6.5 Fan]

Keyless, got a nice one from Accusize.

 

[terry_g]

I have both but use the keyless by far the most. I picked up a pair of 5/8" Metabo chucks from BusyBee years ago when I bought the lathe and mill.

 

[Mcgyver]

If only one, keyed. Tapping is a frequent lathe op and I've had them come loose when being reversed (happened on the mill, but same principle applies)

 

[Susquatch]

If only one, keyed. Tapping is a frequent lathe op and I've had them come loose when being reversed (happened on the mill, but same principle applies)

This is why I chose to use a collet instead. Never had it happen but leary of the event and very aware of the possibility. Finally found a nice 3/4" keyed chuck for tapping. Just waiting on an arbour for it.

 

[DavidR8]

Keyed and keyless it is gents.
Many thanks!

 

[jgimp69]

I’ve never used a keyless chuck on a lathe. I don’t think I’ve ever come across a keyless on a MT at all. Usually I’m flipping from the keyed chuck to a MT drill or live centre anyways so often as opposed to keeping the chuck in the tailstock that I don’t think it’s enough of a production scenario to justify like it is on a mill. That said, for home use maybe something to consider if I can find one for a reasonable cost.

 

[Susquatch]

I’ve never used a keyless chuck on a lathe. I don’t think I’ve ever come across a keyless on a MT at all.

My Southbend Keyless has an integrated MT3 shank. Nice chuck to use on a lathe. It's no Albrecht, but still very nice.

 

[jgimp69]

My Southbend Keyless has an integrated MT3 shank. Nice chuck to use on a lathe. It's no Albrecht, but still very nice.

I could definitely see using a keyless on smaller lathes. On most jobs I’ve always used 14N or 16N chucks and Ive usually only centre drilled for live centres or flipped to MT drills.
I’m now thinking about a keyless on my Colchester at home though

 

[YYCHM]

 

[Dabbler]

Keyed or Keyless?

The answer is yes.

yes this.

If only one, keyed.

agreed.

I have both keyed and keyless on 2 of my lathes and keyed only on the big one. I mostly use the keyed chucks. For me they have been less trouble. I understand if I were to buy a really high end keyless one it would convert me over forever (or so they say). I'm willing to give it a try if I could find one in my affordability range. the cheap keyless ones are.... cheap.

 

[Andy G]

I realized today that I don't have a tailstock chuck for the new lathe.
Question for the group: do I get a keyed or keyless chuck?

For up to 1/2" keyless works for me. I have a Rohm. Beautiful tool!

 

[Susquatch]

I have a 5/8" keyed chuck that came with my lathe. I hardly ever use it. My goto is a keyless Southbend 5/8 MT3 I got on Amazon and I like it. I just bought a bigger used Keyed 3/4" chuck but I'm having trouble finding a key for it.

My vote is for a quality keyless chuck.

 

[cuslog]

Keyless are great for light to medium use -- not so great for heavy duty use -- the harder you work 'em the tighter they'll twist (tighten) themselves to the point of self destruction if you keep feeding them in.

 

[Dabbler]

I use a Jacobs keyed chuck in mine. I bought a cheaper keyless one and it sucked. I'm sure a Rohm or other top-tier keyless will do well, but my keyed has held demming bits up to 1 1/6 without problem, so I'm not motivated to find a keyless one.